Ultra-sleek, but not the main game

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

This was published 11 years ago

Ultra-sleek, but not the main game

By DAVID POGUE

What is an ultrabook?

It is an absolutely gorgeous, sleek wedge of a laptop, clad in shining brushed metal. There is no DVD drive. The battery is sealed and non-removable. The keys protrude through individual square holes in the laptop's deck. The multitouch trackpad is buttonless — you get different clicks by pressing different spots. You generally need a separate adaptor dongle if you want to connect to ethernet or a VGA projector.

Ultrabooks at the 2012 CES tradeshow . . . great if you can stop running your hands across the cool, polished metal.

Ultrabooks at the 2012 CES tradeshow . . . great if you can stop running your hands across the cool, polished metal.

And there is no hard drive. Instead, you get a solid-state drive, or SSD, which is like a giant memory card. It helps with battery life and fast start-up times.

Those expensive SSDs make ultrabooks ultra-expensive ($900 and up), and you get very little storage, usually 128 gigabytes. In a laptop with a regular hard drive, you can get eight times that much storage — for a lot less money.

So what is an ultrabook? It's MacBook Air that runs Windows.

That's just about everybody's description — except Intel, which developed the concept. ("Was the MacBook Air an inspiration for this category?" I asked Intel's PR team. "No," was the answer. "The Ultrabook category was conceptualised out of multiple rounds of research going back several years." Well, chalk up one for mind-blowing coincidence.)

Because of the tiny storage, an ultrabook does not make a good primary computer and can store only wee photo, music and video collections. Forget high-horsepower games, too. And to install software, you'll either have to buy an external DVD drive or stick to downloadable software.

But never mind all that. If you have the money, you'll love how satisfying, beautiful and exquisitely designed these machines made by the major PC makers are. For most uses — email, web surfing, chat, Microsoft Office, music, streaming movies — an ultrabook is pure joy. If, that is, you can stop running your hands over the cool, polished metal.

Advertisement

A MacBook Air still has the best combination of design, screen, keyboard, trackpad and battery life. But ultrabooks come close, and they offer the advantages of choice. For example, ultrabooks come in larger screen sizes, like 14 inches (Hewlett-Packard) and 15 inches (Samsung). You can buy an ultrabook with a nong-lossy screen — the colours are not as vibrant, but you do not get annoying reflections. Most ultrabooks have dedicated keys that Apple leaves out, like Home, End, Page Up and Page Down.

Finally, most ultrabooks cost less than an Air, which is $1450 for the 13-inch model.

I tested ultrabooks from Acer, Asus, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, Lenovo, Samsung and Toshiba. Most have identical guts: 4GB memory, a 128GB SSD, Intel Core i5 processor, a 13-inch glossy screen (1366 x 768 pixels), an SD slot for your camera's memory card, two or three USB jacks (including a USB 3.0 for faster charging of gadgets), a miniature HDMI jack for connecting to a TV, a web camera, mike/headphone jacks and illuminated keys. Most weigh less than 1.5 kilograms and get about six hours on a charge. In most cases, you can pay more for a bigger SSD (256 gigabytes) and faster Intel i7 processor.

Despite those similarities, they have personalities all their own:

Acer Aspire S3 ($800) — you read that price right: This is the least expensive ultrabook so far.

To reach that price, Acer kind of cheated. The SSD is small (20GB) and holds only start-up files; all your files go onto a traditional 320GB hard drive. Result: lower price, more storage, slower laptop.

More compromises: The keys feel like you're typing on concrete. The cursor keys are the size of Tic Tacs. Also, only the top is metal (a gorgeous muted silver). The keyboard, deck, palm rest and bottom are all plastic. The battery life is not great — about five hours.

Asus Zenbook UX31E (from about $1300) — gorgeous dark grey metal lid, Bang & Olufsen circuitry for slightly richer sound. But the keyboard does not light up, and the keys do not travel much. You press the left and right lower corners of the trackpad to produce right- and left-clicks but mine often produced the wrong kind of click.

The screen has higher resolution than most (1600 x 900), meaning that you can see more without scrolling (at smaller size). An 11-inch model is also available.

Dell XPS 13 ($1200) — "Dell" and "gorgeous" do not generally appear in the same sentence. But the aluminum top, carbon fibre bottom and satisfying keyboard make this ultrabook a look-and-feel triumph. It is thicker than most ultrabooks but a whole inch shallower, so you can still work when the joker in front of you reclines his plane seat.

Sadly, there is no memory-card slot, HDMI port, navigation keys or ethernet jack (you can buy an ethernet dongle). The trackpad never misses your clicks but its multitouch response is flaky.

Lenovo IdeaPad U300s ($US1050) — not sold in Australia but some consumers have imported it online. This solid, thin, exquisitely engineered black beauty does not taper from front to back; instead, the top and bottom panels (available in charcoal or orange) protrude slightly, like the covers of a book. This machine is unbelievably pleasurable to use.

Typing feels great – some engineer gave each keystroke just the right amount of movement and click. The trackpad is also superb.

Only two omissions mar the perfection: no memory-card slot and no ethernet jack. Otherwise: mmmm.

Samsung Notebook Series 9 ($1500 for the 11.6-inch model) — the black aluminum-alloy lid feels incredibly silky; just touching it is good for the soul. The screen is bright and vibrant — and it is non-glossy. Thumbs-up on the keyboard, trackpad, weight (a little more than one kilogram) and battery. The only heartbreaker is the nosebleed pricetag.

Toshiba Portégé Z830 ($1721.50) — this laptop is a delightful outlier for four reasons. First, it is the world's lightest ultrabook. It even feels a little hollow, and the screen flexes like a piece of shirt cardboard — but, at just over one kilogram, it practically needs a paperweight.

Second, it is the only ultrabook with a full suite of full-size jacks. There is a real ethernet socket, a real VGA port for projectors, a real HDMI port for TV sets. You even get an extra USB socket (three in all). How great not to have to pack a bunch of dumb little dongles!

Third, there are dedicated buttons beneath the trackpad. They are plastic chrome fingerprint magnets, but at least they never miss a click.

Finally, this pricey model has 6Gb of memory instead of the usual 4 — thanks, Tosh!

Hewlett-Packard Envy 14 Spectre ($1900) — glass, baby. Nearly this entire laptop — lid, screen, keyboard deck — is covered with Gorilla glass, the supertough glass of iPhones and iPads. Not metal.

That bold, original, shiny, fingerprinty design makes this laptop much heavier than most (1.7 kilograms). And pricier. But you get full-size ethernet and HDMI ports, a glorious screen (1600 x 900), good sound, very good keyboard and one of the best Windows trackpads ever. Free copies of Photoshop Elements and Premiere Elements take the sting out of the price.

(The price-conscious may be more interested in HP's more conventional ultrabook, the $1500 Folio, notable for its astonishing eight-hour battery life.)

If you like the ultrabook concept, you'll love the Lenovo and Dell for getting all of the essentials right; the Samsung for its screen and materials; or the lighter-than-Air Toshiba.

But if you wait, more goodness is coming. The northern autumn crop will include faster Intel chips and, in some cases, touchscreens and Windows 8.

Loading

Either way, an ultrabook can bring you many pleasures.

The New York Times

Most Viewed in Technology

Loading