Skip to Main Content
PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Author of Cell Phone Unlocking Petition Makes Final Push for 100K Signatures

The organizers behind a White House petition to legalize phone unlocking are making one last push for 100,000 signatures before the petition expires on Saturday.

By Chloe Albanesius
February 20, 2013
The Best Unlocked Phones

The organizers behind a White House petition to legalize phone unlocking are making one last push for 100,000 signatures before the petition expires on Saturday.

The petition, submitted to the White House's "We the People" online petition site, calls on the administration to make unlocking cell phones legal. It has gained more than 86,000 e-signatures, but needs 100,000 or more by Feb. 23 for a formal White House response.

At issue is an October decision from the Library of Congress's Copyright Office, which gave consumers a 90-day window to unlock their phones without carrier permission before that practice became illegal in January.

The Copyright Office reviews the rules on unlocking (and jailbreaking) every three years, as required by the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). This time around, regulators found that "there are ample alternatives to circumvention. That is, the marketplace has evolved such that there is now a wide array of unlocked phone options available to consumers."

The creator of the White House petition, Sina Khanifar, disagreed. "Consumers will be forced to pay exorbitant roaming fees to make calls while traveling abroad. It reduces consumer choice, and decreases the resale value of devices that consumers have paid for in full," he wrote on his petition.

Groups like the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), meanwhile, argued that the decision will open up regular mobile phone users to carrier lawsuits.

Khanifar has some experience with lawsuits. He was sued by Motorola in 2005 for selling software that unlocked their phones.

"I started unlocking phones after a typical entrepreneurial experience: I had a problem and was forced to find a solution. I'd brought a cell phone from California to use while at college in the UK, but quickly discovered that it wouldn't work with any British cell networks," Khanifar wrote in a blog post. "The phone was locked. Strapped for cash and unable to pay for a new phone, I figured out how to change the Motorola firmware to unlock the device."

Ultimately, Khanifar started selling his unlocking software via Cell-Unlock.com, a business that picked up with the release of the Motorola Razr. At that point, Khanifar said he received a cease and desist from Motorola, which claimed he was violated the DMCA and could face up to $500,000 in fines and five years in jail per offense.

"My immediate reaction was to shut down the business," Khanifar wrote, but he started working with Jennifer Granick, founder of Stanford's Cyberlaw Clinic, who has also held posts at the EFF and the Center for Internet and Society. She battled the suit pro bono and ultimately got Motorola to back down and secured a win on unlocking overall.

"In the year after helping me with my case, Jennifer Granick fought for an exemption from the DMCA for unlocking phones, and in November 2006 it was granted," Khanifar wrote. "That exemption was in place for 6 years, until the Library of Congress and the Copyright Office decided to remove it this past November."

Khanifar has since passed control of Cell-Unlock.com to his brother, and the site is not taking any orders from the U.S. right now. Khanifar's main focus at the moment is OpenSignal, which provides crowd-sourced cell carrier coverage maps.

The White House recently increased the threshold for an official response from 25,000 to 100,000 after a number of questionable petitions (see the slideshow above) easily hit that 25,000 mark.

Of course, even if the unlocking petition surpasses 100,000 e-signatures, that does not guarantee that the White House will back a reversal of the Copyright Office's decision. But it will be forced to formally address the issue rather than deferring to the Copyright Office.

The unlocking ruling, meanwhile, does not affect jailbreaking, which the Copyright Office found to be legal for smartphones.

To sign Khanifar's petition, you must create a whitehouse.gov account and click "Sign This Petition."

UPDATE: The petition successfully topped 100,000 signatures Wednesday night, meaning the White House is required to respond. Khanifar said work on the issue will continue via fixthedmca.org; sign up there for updates about this campaign.

For more from Chloe, follow her on Twitter @ChloeAlbanesius.

Like What You're Reading?

Sign up for Fully Mobilized newsletter to get our top mobile tech stories delivered right to your inbox.

This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time.


Thanks for signing up!

Your subscription has been confirmed. Keep an eye on your inbox!

Sign up for other newsletters

TRENDING

About Chloe Albanesius

Executive Editor for News

I started out covering tech policy in Washington, D.C. for The National Journal's Technology Daily, where my beat included state-level tech news and all the congressional hearings and FCC meetings I could handle. After a move to New York City, I covered Wall Street trading tech at Incisive Media before switching gears to consumer tech and PCMag. I now lead PCMag's news coverage and manage our how-to content.

Read Chloe's full bio

Read the latest from Chloe Albanesius