Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

People are more satisfied with the Apple Watch than any other smartwatch, but not by much

Bentley Apple Watch app
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Even though Apple entered the smartwatch market in April 2015, the Cupertino-based company’s Apple Watch is in charge when it comes to customer satisfaction, but not by much, according to J.D. Power’s 2016 Smartwatch Device Satisfaction Report.

The report measured overall satisfaction with smartwatches, based on a 1,000-point scale, among 2,696 respondents who bought a smartwatch within the last 12 months, as well as with fitness band trackers among 2,949 respondents who purchased one of those devices within the last 12 months. Respondents were fielded questions in May and June.

In the smartwatch arena, Apple topped the satisfaction rankings with 852 points, with strong performance in terms of comfort, styling and appearance, and ease of use. However, Samsung was not too far behind, with the company garnering 842 points and strong performance in terms of customer service, display size, and phone features. Contextually, average customer satisfaction with smartwatches stood at 847 points.

However, respondents did have issues with whatever smartwatch they owned, with 19 percent saying they experienced at least one problem. 29 percent of respondents had an issue with the battery either not lasting as long as they like or not charging at all, with 23 percent having difficulties with customization and 22 percent experiencing a broken charger.

Moving on to the fitness band tracker section, Samsung took the reigns with 859 points, with special attention given to comfort, reliability, and ease of use. With 836 points, however, Garmin is breathing down Samsung’s neck, with strong performance in terms of customer service, ease of use, strength and durability, and reliability.

Of note is Jawbone, which sees its market share continue to cede ground to Apple, Fitbit, and Xiaomi, with a customer satisfaction score of 814, below the report average of 829 points. Also below that average are LG, which garnered 827 points, and Fitbit, which sits at 826 points.

When it comes to why respondents selected their currently fitness band device, positive reviews played fourth fiddle to ease of use (48 percent), price (40 percent), and brand reputation (38 percent).

Not a great time to be a wearable

Interestingly, Pebble was not listed in either smartwatch or fitness band category in the report. The company has somewhat struggled as of late, laying off 40 of its employees in March. Furthermore, money has been hard to come by, according to CEO Eric Migicovsky, with Pebble focusing on health and fitness features moving forward.

Pebble is hardly the only company in the wearable game that is struggling, with Fitbit’s stock going south and the Apple Watch constantly getting price cuts. Jawbone, meanwhile, laid off 15 percent of its workforce in November, though the company assured customers it will not exit the wearable game anytime soon. In addition, LG is the only manufacturer on the list to still be in the Android Wear business, which makes us wonder how Google’s wearable operating system is doing in terms of sales.

Editors' Recommendations

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
Apple may have delayed a critical Apple Watch upgrade
Smart Stack on the Apple Watch Series 9.

It seems Apple’s highly anticipated display upgrades, especially for the Apple Watch, will have to wait a few more years. According to Bloomberg, Apple has shuttered in-house efforts to design and develop microLED panels that would have appeared on its smartwatches — and eventually more products down the road.

The current-gen Apple smartwatches rely on an OLED panel, but Apple has been eyeing microLED screens for the Apple Watch's future iterations. These in-house panels, which would have offered “brighter and more vibrant visuals,” were ultimately put on cold ice due to cost and complexity concerns.

Read more
Why you shouldn’t buy a new Apple Watch right now
The curved screen on the Apple Watch Series 9.

It has been over six months since the Apple Watch Series 9 and Apple Watch Ultra 2 launched, and they are still considered two of the best smartwatches on the market. However, there are two significant reasons why you might not want to purchase either of these models.

Those reasons are the Apple Watch Series 8 and the first-generation Apple Watch Ultra. That's right — buying a 2022 Apple Watch over the newer models might be a better choice for you.
Why now's a great time to buy an old Apple Watch
The Apple Watch Series 9 (top) and Apple Watch Series 8 Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Read more
8 watches you should buy instead of an Apple Watch
A person wearing the Apple Watch Series 9.

The Apple Watch Series 9 is the best smartwatch you can buy, regardless of the fact you can only use it with an iPhone. It's also great that it comes in three flavors — the Series 9, along with the Apple Watch SE 2, and the Apple Watch Ultra 2 — to suit many more people and pockets than you may first think. However, perhaps you want something a little different on your wrist or even a weekend alternative when you don’t feel like wearing a touchscreen watch.

That’s where this list should help you out, as we’ve gathered eight watches to buy instead of the Apple Watch. Notice I said “watches,” and not just smartwatches, as some non-connected wristwear has been included. Our choices cover the entire Apple Watch range in terms of price, even going above and below, to give you some real inspiration about a watch to buy instead of — or as well as — the superb Apple Watch.
Casio G-Shock GPR-H1000 Rangeman
Casio G-Shock Rangeman Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Read more